I had no plans on buying a liner at this price point but I got sucked into it while a purchase. Ill say this. Its incredibly smooth gliding and doesn't skip. But I don't feel like its super black, not super pigmented. I know its not marketed as "waterproof" but I had smudges under my wing after just an hour. This is fine and dandy to wear around the house or out for a few errands but I wouldn't stand up to FULL day of wear. Another surratt fail for me, money down the drain unfortunately. I do wish they accepted returns on items that did not meet a customers satisfaction, these items cost too much to just eat the loss.