This product has blown me away. I have never been happy with the way any liquid liner looks on me. The lines always seem too harsh for my fair coloring for everyday use and now that I'm older that problem is worse. Dragging pencils across my less than taut lids was an exercise in frustration. Stretching my lids worked, but resulted in lines with weird endings. I went back to liquid, but the pens and brushes never gave me the precision I wanted and I ended up with globs or sections of the line that were too thick. Also, it wasn't FUN to use them, but a bit of a chore. This liner in Brun Riche has changed everything for me. It goes on so smoothly and beautifully, and you can add a second coat if you want a more dramatic line. The shade of brown is perfect - not so dark it looks brown, but not too light. A Goldylocks shade! Once I figured out how hard I needed to press to install the refill, I was ready to go and haven't looked back. This product is a "ride or die" for me! Thank you, Troy Surratt!